The Sanctuary Survey - Keeping Obama & McCain honest on immigration
The pro-Migrant bloggers over at the The Sanctuary website are making national news by trying to do a very difficult thing: keep Obama and McCain honest about their immigration agenda. It seems that in an effort to catch the majority of the ever growing “Latino vote,” Obama and McCain are flip flopping all over themselves, changing what they say depending on what audience they are speaking to.
So in June, the folks at The Sanctuary made a basic request; they asked each candidate to respond to a 38 Question Candidate Survey. You can probably guess the response. Neither candidate has completed the survey nor, until the Survey made national news, had either candidate even responded.
From CNN’s report on The Survey:
Kety Esquivel, Christian progressive blogger, founder of Crossleft.org: Well, I think one of the things that has given us pause as a community has been the flip-flopping, has been him going back and forth on different issues that are important to our community. So if, for example, he says to our community in a closed- door room meeting –
Kiran Chetry, CNN Anchor: You’re talking about McCain here?
Esquivel: Correct. If he says to us one thing, we want to be able to see that that’s the same thing that he thinks (says to) the American populace as a whole. Unfortunately, we haven’t seen that consistency. And that’s I think what’s giving a lot of people pause.
Here are a few questions from the survey:
1. Could you please articulate what you think are the most pressing issues for the U.S. immigrant community, at home AND abroad, and how you would hope to address those issues as President?
2. Do you support comprehensive immigration reform?
Yes No
Please explain.
How long have you held this position?3. What policy conditions would comprehensive immigration reform have to meet in order for you to support it? Please be specific?
4. Do you support the establishment of an expanded guest worker program?
Yes No
Please explain.
How long have you held this position?
I joked with my amigo Nezua over at the Unapologetic Mexican that the “how long have you held this position” would do both Obama and McCain in. And I suggested the question might instead be “how long will you hold this position?”
But immigration policy is no laughing matter. Hundreds of thousands of people, who are working to support America’s spine, toil in harsh labor conditions and are being abused by employers who choose to take advantage of cheap undocumented labor. Part of the reason immigrant labor is so cheap is that employers do not want to provide basic worker protections mandated automatically for US Citizens, so they hire people without papers.
Do not be hoodwinked into an overly simplified “they” are taking our jobs screed. Don’t blame people for coming to this country to work hard. Confront employers only hiring illegal workers. Find out if they are paying minimum wages and providing legal benefits. Demand changes in the system that allows employers to brazenly break the law in the chase of massive profit.




























Posted by: Carmen D. in 

“I suggested the question might instead be “how long will you hold this position?””
All so true. I don’t think people really pay attention to what these candidates are saying/not saying about issues.
“Confront employers only hiring illegal workers. Find out if they are paying minimum wages and providing legal benefits. Demand changes in the system”
So many people seem to want to blame the immigrants when it is the employers (including the government) who are allowing all this to happen.
July 16th, 2008 at 9:12 am -the employers are mightily to blame for exploiting cheap labor, and this one BIG reason that the Republicans are soft on illegals. Then we have the Democrats, who are ultra soft on illegals because they are not white. If all the illegal immigrants were from eastern Europe, the Dems would be silent.
As for myself, I once was instigating a newspaper for illegals in my area - truly so - up until I saw the flood of marches with *illegal* unentitled complainers holding up the signs that said “whites are racist” and all of that. Ever since then I prefer to have every single one deported… and am politically active in that direction. One thing that really gets my ire up is the injustice of any kind - and that most especially includes politically-correct bigotry.
Oh, and if illegal immigrants were all from eastern Europe, then legal Mexican-Americans would not be so fervently supporting them, to be sure. So who is the real racist? Viva la rasa, eh?
July 16th, 2008 at 8:21 pm -The best solution for ending the abuse of illegals here in this country is to send them back to their own country where they will be protected by their own labor laws and treated with respect.
July 28th, 2008 at 12:20 am -