Home » Barack Obama, Pet Peeves, Political Correctness?, Politics

A magic negro?: All About Race rewind

By Carmen D. on Saturday, December 27th, 2008, 2:11 am Comments

I wrote this post in March of 2007. Given GOP candidate Chip Saltsman’s decision to distribute Rush Limbaugh radio show humor to colleagues, I thought ‘A magic negro?’ was worth revisiting. As always, I’d appreciate your comments.

Yesterday, the Los Angeles Times published a highly offensive, overly simplistic piece about Barack Obama. Titled “Obama, the Magical Negro”, it makes no difference that the author, David Ehrenstein, is African American. Ehrenstein doesn’t get it. The term ‘magic Negro’ was coined in the 1950’s to describe a particular kind of black presence in film and literature. The ‘magic Negro’, or what Spike Lee calls the ‘super duper magical Negro’, sometimes has special powers that serve to enlighten or make better their white counterparts. At the end of the story, the ‘magic Negro’ dies or disappears while the white characters go on, enlightened and enriched in some way. John Coffey in Stephen King’s The Green Mile and Whoopi Goldberg’s character in Ghost are two clear examples of this idea.

Why then would Ehrenstein apply this term to a real, live, viable black presidential candidate? I don’t know. Ehrenstein posits that a key part of Obama’s campaign strategy is to be seen as non-confrontational and likable. Well, to indulge in vernacular, I say, “DUH”. At this point on the campaign trail it is sound strategy for every candidate to be perceived as likeable and non-threatening. Both Hillary Clinton and Rudy Giuliani are twisting themselves like pretzels to be perceived as likeable and non-threatening; whatever that actually means.

Ehrenstein seems to think that Barack Obama is perceived to be safe by ‘white America’. No way, it’s not that simple. The hard truth is that for many in America, particularly in the middle of the country and in parts of the south, there is no such thing as a non-threatening black man. We don’t hear about hate mail or death threats endured by Obama and his family. But don’t you think those threats are coming at a rate only the great Hank Aaron might comprehend?

I am so sick of individual black people judging the ‘blackness’ of other black people. It is simply a waste of time and energy that we, as a community, can ill afford.

  • David Ehrenstein has written several pieces that are anti-Obama. You guys really should get familiar with this man's story. I wrote a fairly comprehensive post on my blog about him and his attacks on Obama that might be worth a read if anyone's interested. By the way, David Ehrenstein is bi-racial(half black/half jewish). He's also openly gay.

    http://unclefatlips.com/top-feature/will-the-re...
  • Celestine
    Carmen, I wondered if this would come up on your blog. I have to echo n-2-me-i-c about taking deep breaths, my fear is that as of Jan. 20,2009 I will be hyperventilating.
  • AR
    Carmen, Ehrenstein does not seem to be debating Obama's blackness, but instead he seems to be discussing whether or not Obama will support black interests (which is a valid question). When Ehrenstein discussed how Obama appeared non-confrontational and likeable, you agreed. Yet, you mentioned Clinton appeared the exact same way. I would disagree to a certain extent. Let's talk demographics. Clinton could appeal to the masses ALL THE WHILE proclaiming how great it is that she is a female-candidate, and how she plans to look out for female interests. Obama could not afford to vocally embrace his blackness in the same way. Why? Because America is much more sensitive to female issues, than black issues. Obama did what made whites comfortable, understandably. But, the black community should and must ask, was his failure to discuss systematic racism a campaign strategy, or will it be his policy now that he is elected. We, in the black community, have got to stop falling in love with leaders, and hold them accountable. If Obama plans to keep making whites comfortable at the expense of African American interests, he should lose our support. Should we support someone who is too afraid to represent our interests once elected? Just because someone criticizes Obama, does not mean that the person is jealous or judging his blackness, it could mean that that person is doing what Obama said we should all do--hold him accountable. In Corporate America, many black employees don't want to work for black supervisors, because some black supervisors have a tendency to want to show everyone they are not showing favoritism to the black employee. I don't want this to be the situation with Obama. I agree, calling anyone "a magical negro" is offensive, but exploring the substance behind Obama's rhetoric is not.
  • n-2-me-i-c
    I think this will be considered mild stuff compared to what's coming in 2009. I hope Obama, his family, and others will be able to rise above the hurtful words...esp. African-Americans.

    I sometimes forget, but I try to REMEMBER to take a deep breath or two when these insulting moments arise. The GOP and their supporters have already begun... and Obama hasn't even started.
  • Hey JP! I see your point. But my thoughts on Ehrenstein are a little darker...(pun intended?) For instance, Ehrenstein certainly could have selected Will Smith's character in "Independence Day" as a construct for what Obama was striving to achieve.

    Folks of all colors loved that character too - and he had nuclear bombs.
  • JP
    The term "Magic Negro" is just a convenient construct. David Ehrenstein proclaims that he writes about "Hollywood and politics" as that is what he purportedly knows, or thinks he knows, so it is not surprising that in his effort to understand the Obama phenomenon he would try to make sense out of the Obama success in the terms his mind can grasp.


    That in no way validates the construct as anything other than what it is, a "short-hand" industry insider term that may only apply in that industry. Where Ehrenstein failed was trying to create a world outside of this construct to fit his script. If I can stay with his "life is a movie" scenario, then I can explain the Obama phenomenon in much simpler movie terms.

    "CUT!" "Get rid of the village idiot" (another Hollywood construct). Exit Bush, stage right.
blog comments powered by Disqus