Home » Black voices & White voices

Black voices & White voices

From My post at AOL Black Voices/BlackSpin:

I don’t live in a different world from any other American. But I experience that world as an individual, through the prism of my identity which consists of many elements including “race” as the concept has manifested in this country. As a black woman, I don’t see the world as a white male or white woman does. Another example, as an able bodied woman, my experiences are different from a disabled person’s. It would be uninformed for me to presume that although I am a supporter of the Disabled Rights movement, that our news and information priorities are always the same.

This is perhaps a long wind up to get to the question I’d like to address here. Frequently, visitors to the AOL site ask this:

Why no “WhiteVoices?” This continues to segregate no matter how you sell it. Maybe just “Voices‚” or “REGIONAL VOICES?” Just sets things back further. Not much of an INDEPENDENCE DAY positive movement. Really look beyond colors would ya???

My first reaction is always to wonder if these same people write to Time, Newsweek, Huffington Post, AOL’s Fanhouse or any other online forum host about the preponderance of white opinion on those pages.

It seems somehow that many white people do not see “white” as its own race and influencer on personal experience. They see black, brown, gold and America. Or they see black, brown, gold and “the rest of us.” They don’t think in terms that no matter what you call majority white opinion and news organizations, they are predominately and in essence “white voices.”

Those “mainstream,” i.e. white majority, forums generate topics and focus attention on issues editors decide are important to their primary readership – as does “Black Voices.” Like “Black Voices,” those staffs are racially integrated and articles are open to anyone to read and comment on.

One of the ideas I most oppose is the notion that recognizing differences in American experience is “setting things back further” or “divisive.” I really do not understand that. In my ideal America, we respect and honor the vibrant diversity of the United States. We see each others experiences and listen to what each other has to say and from that exchange we forge a fuller understanding of the world. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. talked about being judged on the content of one’s character. Dr. King never, ever suggested that a person’s skin color would have to be rendered unspeakable or invisible in order for them to be considered equal.

  • fairshake
    I think a lot of history is getting left out, not just black history. I grew up in the 50's, 60's etc. I also grew up in Florida. I witnessed some people with racism and I also witnessed some people with no racism. I feel I am not racist. I was appalled when anyone would treat someone badly and many times called them on their actions. Had I lived in Mississippi or Alabama, I'd probably be dead right now. I would have definitely earned they common label of the time: N lover. Such a disgusting word. Slavery was bad and it should have never happened, but it did and we can't change history. We must move forward and make new history. I just can't see holding onto the anger and living in the past; their are injustices out there for all races and there will always be as we do not live in perfect world. You fight them one at a time. It serves no purpose to blatantly claim everything done to a person of color is racially motivated because the initiator is white. It seems to me, the only people who can't move past race are blacks. I am female. I have been discriminated against plenty of times by men of my own race, yet I do not cry foul everytime something happens to me and I don't ask for special favors. I suck it up and move on. It is their loss, not mine. I think to move past race and racism, we need to take those words out of every form we fill out.
  • This information can turn the tide for Mumia. Go to: www.wecpro.blogspot.com
  • smittyt
    one day people will wake up and see there,s just ain,t no way you can live in peace with the white race you might see people that think their getting along with them but it,s always gonna be they on top you on the bottom they always gonna think their smarter then you and everything is gonna have to be their way because they get mad fast when a black person say something to them they don,t like they feelings get hurt fast and, there ain,t no way in the world am kissing nobody ass to get along with them they reall y ain,t worth the trouble.
  • fairshake
    Smittyt, I agree with you in the context that not everyone is going to get along. Heck, the Middle East have been fighting for thousands of years. This is a human trait that will always be with us. Having said this, where you are wrong is assuming that all whites think they are smarter than you. I for one can not assume this. For all I know you could have an IQ as high or higher than Einstein. I don't know you, you don't me. I also am not mad at you for saying what you said. This is how you feel. I also ain't gonna kiss anybody's ass. They either like me or they don't. I won't shed any tears if they don't. See we do have some common ground.
  • namekimby303
    First of all i never blamed white people for selling us in to slavery.And i do not blame anyone for my failures which are few,my life has been very productive.Iam very aware of the part some blacks played in slavery,. You made my point with all of your childish rants,why did you feel the need to tell me to shut the hell up?what i didnt ask your permission to voice my opinion? Sorry master(ha-ha)My reference to slavery was made to show how one group of people had control over another group of people. You obviously did'nt understand the comment, I think you just are so angry that you needed to yell at a black person. Say what you want just don't tell me"TO SHUT THE HELLUP"!
  • Harvey
    From High school on we were told to sit down, hush up, PAY UP(it is not yours, it be mines), etc. Why would any of us give a damn. It is just as bad to be a conservative white man as it is to be a black conservative. My family is mixed. God punishes those of us who judge poorly, and unfairly. No one wants to hear a white voice say "back off," "stand on your own feet," etc. It only increases the African American anger thus has little value. You keep your race. You all kill each other in record numbers and the voice we hear is how evil and bad every other race is.
  • johncalloway
    I just want to take a quick a minute and discuss black history month. In my opinion I think it is a bunch of B.S. The blacks feel they need a month to recognize there struggle and uprisings. Well what about the white race or the Native American race or even the Asian race. What about them. All races have struggled and had to "uprise" but the blacks are the only race that expect recognition from the whole damn country. The black race wants to be equal but act as if they deserve more. BET, Ebony magazine, the NAACP. I think we should have a WET (White Entertainment Television), A Caucasian magazine, and an organization set up for the main purpose of making sure the White Americans receive equal rights. The Native Americans owned the whole country and was raped, murdered, and lied to but you do not see them screaming racism.
  • GabbyT
    Shut the hell up! Your race was not strong enough to fight the white man and keep him from taking your land then that's the american indian's fault, not the black man.
  • Michelle
    @johncalloway

    Black History was started by a black man, and it was started because basically up until the mid-twentieth century, the majority of American black history and our contributions to this country were virtually ignored and shoved inside and rarely even taught,period. White people have had THEIR history and contributions ALWAYS recognized, as if you were the only people who did anything to make this country great, which is total and complete B.S.---hell,y'all own all of the media. Black people having separate organizations and things for ourselves dates back from the time segregation legally existed in this country, which was barely 50 years ago. White folks did NOT want us ANYWHERE they were,period---that's where that comes from. I'm sick of hearing white folks like yourself spouting off and complaining about Black History (which, BTW, is the shortest damn month of the year,anyway) Month when you are completely ignorant of the history behind. Black people didn't segregate themselves because they wanted to---it's because white people FORCED them to. And what the hell do you mean you need a WET? Excuse, but last TIME I looked, T.V. was STILL virtually 98% white, which it ALWAYS has been---except for in the 1970's with GOOD TIMES and all those other shows.

    BET was created because for a change because we wanted to see a T.V. channel that dealt with US and OUR issues for a change, with shows with people that LOOKED like us. White folks ALWAYS see anybody that looks like them 100% of the time. And Native Americans are still having racist acts perpetuated against them--you just don't hear about it as much. SO shut up whining with you white privileged behind and check out some history FOR a change. Hell,yeah, we want our contributions recognized because we DID contribute a hell of a lot to this country--as well as nearly 400 years of free slave labor beaten out of us--because our contributions were virtually ignored for the 1st 350 years we were here.

    Here's the man who started Black History. Now read it and shut up and learn for a change.
  • Chris Summerfield
    Well hello again Carmen. I must say, I'm dissapointed that this blog has fell off in recent times and seems to have been relegated to being lost in the mix of so many other subjects. Perhaps a downsizing and streamlining of the total amount of blogs is necessary. It's just that I'm sure there are lots of black and white people with strong feelings on this most important issue, I'm just not too sure that they have knowledge of it's existance. Any thoughts?
blog comments powered by Disqus